Karma XPU vs Redshift - A Comprehensive Review

If you're interested in downloading the scene files for yourself, then visit this link: https://www.cgforge.com/karma-rs-review-file

Timestamps:

00:00:00 - Intro 00:01:47 - Testing Criteria

Criteria 1: Speed

00:02:47 - How Scenes Were Tested 00:10:50 - Shaderbot Lineup 00:11:28 - Adaptive Tessellation 00:11:38 - Bubble Blob 00:12:25 - Caustics 00:12:35 - Global Illumination 00:13:31 - Volume Rendering 00:14:10 - Motion Blur 00:14:20 - Instancing 00:14:31 - Stability 00:15:01 - Shaderbot Commentary 00:17:10 - Tessellation Commentary 00:18:19 - Bubble Blob Commentary 00:21:29 - Caustics Commentary 00:22:43 - Global Illumination Commentary 00:25:03 - Volume Rendering Commentary 00:26:22 - Motion Blur 00:27:08 - Instancing Test

Criteria 2: Features

00:29:04 - Considerations for Features 00:29:44 - Features List 00:30:29 - Features Commentary

Criteria 3: User Experience

00:31:15 - Redshift Documentation 00:33:55 - Karma Documentation 00:37:19 - Redshift Color Correction 00:39:11 - Karma Color Correction 00:42:06 - Redshift Viewport Integration 00:42:37 - Karma Solaris Viewport Overrides 00:46:08 - Renderview Comparisons 00:47:40 - PostFX 00:48:42 - Karma Viewport Render Settings 00:49:54 - Render Settings Comparison 00:51:49 - Commentary About USD

Criteria 4: Pricing

00:54:51 - Houdini Pricing 00:56:00 - Redshift Pricing 00:56:21 - Pricing Breakdown Scenario

Criteria 5: Visual Quality

01:00:35 - Defining Visual Quality 01:01:17 - Final Thoughts

For more high quality content, visit https://www.cgforge.com Thanks for watching! ... https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v_KtPsohtAY