If October 7 Justifies The Gaza Genocide, What Acts Of Violence Will The Gaza Genocide Justify?

If October 7 Justifies The Gaza Genocide, What Acts Of Violence Will The Gaza Genocide Justify?

April 22, 2025

ISRAEL IMPERIALISM - FOLLOW THE MONEY

Caitlin Johnstone

If you believe that all the violence and destruction in Gaza is the fault of Hamas, then by your own logic you must also accept that the coming wave of violent extremism and antisemitism which is going to ensue from the incineration of Gaza will exclusively be the fault of Israel.

I said this on Twitter the other day and Israel supporters got outraged and shared screenshots of my post shrieking with indignation that anyone would say such a thing, which is funny because I’m just reading their own line of reasoning back to them.

I’m not the one who says an act of violence excuses any violence done in response to it. I’m not the one who says history automatically restarts at the most recent act of aggression, thereby making any amount of retaliatory violence against civilians a justified response to an unprovoked attack for which the vengeful bear no responsibility. This isn’t my position. It’s theirs.

If you believe that all the violence and destruction in Gaza is the fault of Hamas, then by your own logic you must also accept that the coming wave of violent extremism and antisemitism which is going to ensue from the incineration of Gaza will exclusively be the fault of Israel.

I said this on Twitter the other day and Israel supporters got outraged and shared screenshots of my post shrieking with indignation that anyone would say such a thing, which is funny because I’m just reading their own line of reasoning back to them.

I’m not the one who says an act of violence excuses any violence done in response to it. I’m not the one who says history automatically restarts at the most recent act of aggression, thereby making any amount of retaliatory violence against civilians a justified response to an unprovoked attack for which the vengeful bear no responsibility. This isn’t my position. It’s theirs.

Reading by Tim Foley

Article with supporting links: https://caitlinjohnstone.com.au/2025/04/22/if-october-7-justifies-the-gaza-genocide-what-acts-of-violence-will-the-gaza-genocide-justify

Original: https://youtu.be/jrtIJEu49tw

Thanks for watching! Subscribe to https://www.caitlinjohnst.one for email updates on all my new stuff.

Thanks for watching! Subscribe to https://caitlinjohnstone.com for email updates on all my new stuff.

=

https://www.youtube.com/@CaitlinJohnstone

I write about the end of illusions. 100% reader-funded writer. All works co-authored with my American husband Tim Foley.

Patreon: http://bit.ly/3Lb4SOe Paypal: http://bit.ly/3LcUSnx

Creative Commons Attribution license (reuse allowed)